• News & data
  • Politics & Opinion
  • Lifestyle & Dining
  • Real Estate
  • Special Reports
  • This Week
  • More +
  • Advertise
  • Daily Podcast
  • Events
  • Nominate
  • People on the Move
News & data
  • Crain's Data Center
  • Health Pulse Chicago
  • Economy
  • Education
  • Finance
  • Law
  • Manufacturing
  • More news >>
More news >>
  • Health care
  • Media & marketing
  • Nonprofits & philanthropy
  • Retail & consumer goods
  • Small business
  • Sports
  • Technology
  • Transportation
  • Utilities
Politics & Opinion
  • City & county government
  • Editorials
  • Greg Hinz On Politics
  • Joe Cahill On Business
  • John Pletz On Tech
  • Opinion & columnists
  • More politics & opinion >>
More politics & opinion >>
  • David Greising On Government
  • Rich Miller On Springfield
  • State & federal government
Lifestyle & Dining
  • Architecture & style
  • Arts & culture
  • Before It Hits The Market
  • Best Private Dining
  • Dining
  • Gadgets & tech
  • More lifestyle & dining >>
More lifestyle & dining >>
  • Society & people
  • Travel
  • Wellness & fitness
Real Estate
  • Commercial real estate
  • Residential real estate
  • Before It Hits the Market
Special Reports
  • Crain's Forum: Housing
  • 20 In Their 20s
  • 40 Under 40
  • Best Places To Work
  • Book of Lists
  • Coolest offices
  • More special reports >>
More special reports >>
  • Fast 50
  • The Most Innovative Companies
  • The Most Powerful Women In Chicago Business
  • Notables
  • Privately held companies
  • Publicly held companies
  • Small business guide
  • Tech 50
  • Who's Who 2017
  • Woman Up
More +
  • Academy & Events
  • Advertise
  • People on the Move
  • Custom features
  • Daily Podcast
  • Nominate
Academy & Events
  • Events
  • Academy
Custom features
  • Big dates
  • CIO Awards
  • Colleges
  • Corporate art market
  • Corporate holiday guide
  • Decisions
  • Giving Guide
  • Giving Tuesday
  • Holiday Party Planner
  • Illinois' Healthiest Employers
  • Luxury Auto
  • Luxury Gift Guide
  • Luxury Home
  • MBA Guide
  • Notable
  • Private School Planner
  • Roundtable discussions
  • Small business spotlight
  • Summer party guide
  • Thought leadership
  • Wealth Management
Skip to main content
#LIGHTFOOT100
LGBTQ Chicagoans have a message for the new mayor
Close
Sister Publication Links
  • Advertise
  • Daily Podcast
  • Events
  • Nominate
  • People on the Move
CRAINS-CHICAGO-horizontal-red-wht
Subscribe
  • GEOFF
  • Logout
  • Subscribe
  • News & data
    • Crain's Data Center
    • Health Pulse Chicago
    • Economy
    • Education
    • Finance
    • Law
    • Manufacturing
    • More news >>
    • Barneys files Chapter 11, will close Chicago, Rosemont locations
      River North developer plans almost 500,000 square feet of offices
      TastyTrade invests $20 million in new startup
      Court Clerk Brown challenger shatters fundraising lid
    • Salary Series: Loyola • Removing health job roadblocks • Trump plan could usher in Canadian drugs
      Rule would force hospitals to publish prices • Baxter supports renal care add-on • An eye on shark spines
      Hospital groups: Change patient survey • Livongo's strong IPO • UChicago Medicine gets $17M to fight addiction in prisons
      Salary Series: U of C Medical Center • Social determinants bill introduced • OSF Ventures launches second $75 million VC fund
    • Stock markets' worst day of the year
      Pritzker launches property tax task force
      Stocks suffer worst week of year on Trump trade war, Fed action
      Rivers Casino owner plans another location—and will expand in Des Plaines
    • The most expensive university in the country is also the most popular
      Meet the firebrand stoking the CTU's flammable rhetoric
      DePaul College Prep acquires new campus
      City Colleges budget gets nod from Civic Fed
    • TastyTrade invests $20 million in new startup
      What Monday's market meltdown cost the world's richest people
      Stock markets' worst day of the year
      Hemp exchange startup has Chicago ties
    • Demand for services strains local immigrant group
      The John Paul Stevens they knew
      Retired Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens dies at 99
      Former Freeborn & Peters partner indicted
    • Amazon-induced price cuts are likely to bite Grainger—and soon
      Boeing changing Max flight-control software architecture in wake of FAA testing
      FAA found high risk of emergency after first Boeing Max crash: report
      Despite Trump flap, R.R. Donnelley has started printing the census
    • Health care
    • Media & marketing
    • Nonprofits & philanthropy
    • Retail & consumer goods
    • Small business
    • Sports
    • Technology
    • Transportation
    • Utilities
  • Politics & Opinion
    • City & county government
    • Editorials
    • Greg Hinz On Politics
    • Joe Cahill On Business
    • John Pletz On Tech
    • Opinion & columnists
    • More politics & opinion >>
    • City should study ComEd takeover, aldermen say
      #Lightfoot100: Investing in Chicago’s South and West sides
      Coalition resurrects push for tax hike on pricey property sales
      Business, labor find middle ground on work scheduling ordinance
    • It takes a village to scam your college financial aid office
      Score one for Lightfoot's progressive, pragmatic agenda
      Lightfoot's about to make a bad bet
      The CTU's strike threat is astonishingly tone-deaf
    • DuPage development agency rehires its old boss
      Time for Congress to do its job on guns
      Kinzinger set to run for the U.S. House again
      How much affordable housing is too much?
    • Why airline competition is the wind beneath O'Hare's wings
      How the move downtown is paying off for McDonald's
      Antitrust cops aren’t going easy on the digitally disrupted
      Defuse the property tax bomb
    • Uptake, GE settle dueling lawsuits
      Grand jury probes alleged fraud at Outcome Health
      Livongo shares soar in debut days
      FBI was investigating Outcome Health fraud last year: report
    • Law banning salary history will be life-changing for workers
      Antitrust cops aren’t going easy on the digitally disrupted
      Defuse the property tax bomb
      Ulta Beauty faces its Walgreens moment
    • David Greising On Government
    • Rich Miller On Springfield
    • State & federal government
  • Lifestyle & Dining
    • Architecture & style
    • Arts & culture
    • Before It Hits The Market
    • Best Private Dining
    • Dining
    • Gadgets & tech
    • More lifestyle & dining >>
    • view gallery
      12 photos
      Mint-condition Keck midcentury at an eye-catching price
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Photos: Mint condition mid-century Keck & Keck in Chicago Heights
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Bright and light in Glen Ellyn
      view gallery
      12 photos
      From warehouse to their house in River North
    • Pritzker renews state's film tax credit
      Head of Chicago Sinfonietta to step down
      Smithsonian's new chief has Chicago ties
      This former state senator has produced a play about the Cubs
    • view gallery
      12 photos
      Mint-condition Keck midcentury at an eye-catching price
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Photos: Mint condition mid-century Keck & Keck in Chicago Heights
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Bright and light in Glen Ellyn
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Photos: Light and bright in Glen Ellyn
    • Yes, another food hall. This one is great.
      We review Stephanie Izard's latest spot: Cabra
      The Peninsula has a new chef. Here's our review of its Lobby restaurant.
      Review: City Tap in Fulton Market
    • The onetime detective on the cybersecurity beat at United
      She's running AnitaB.org from Chicago
      Another 'new economy' battle hits Springfield—this time over cars
      Here's what Google's new engineering lab is doing in Chicago
    • Society & people
    • Travel
    • Wellness & fitness
  • Real Estate
    • Commercial real estate
    • Residential real estate
    • Before It Hits the Market
    • River North developer plans almost 500,000 square feet of offices
      ReviewTrackers plans hiring spree as it moves to the Loop
      Last week's most-viewed real estate stories
      Why one far-flung suburb is fed up with this rogue developer
    • Upper-end home sales take steep dive
      Streeterville penthouses hitting market at $14 million-plus—for raw space
      New-home sales: 'We’ve been seeing long-term flatness'
      Chicago-area home price growth weakest in 3½ years
    • view gallery
      12 photos
      Mint-condition Keck midcentury at an eye-catching price
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Photos: Mint condition mid-century Keck & Keck in Chicago Heights
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Bright and light in Glen Ellyn
      view gallery
      12 photos
      Photos: Light and bright in Glen Ellyn
  • Special Reports
    • Crain's Forum: Housing
    • 20 In Their 20s
    • 40 Under 40
    • Best Places To Work
    • Book of Lists
    • Coolest offices
    • More special reports >>
    • Welcome to Crain's Forum
      A note from the publisher on Crain's Forum
      How much affordable housing is too much?
      In suburbs, spiral of decline becomes homeowners' burden
    • Fast 50
    • The Most Innovative Companies
    • The Most Powerful Women In Chicago Business
    • Notables
    • Privately held companies
    • Publicly held companies
    • Small business guide
    • Tech 50
    • Who's Who 2017
    • Woman Up
  • This Week
  • More +
    • Academy & Events
    • Advertise
    • People on the Move
    • Custom features
    • Daily Podcast
    • Nominate
    • Events
    • Academy
    • Big dates
    • CIO Awards
    • Colleges
    • Corporate art market
    • Corporate holiday guide
    • Decisions
    • Giving Guide
    • Giving Tuesday
    • Holiday Party Planner
    • Illinois' Healthiest Employers
    • Luxury Auto
    • Luxury Gift Guide
    • Luxury Home
    • MBA Guide
    • Notable
    • Private School Planner
    • Roundtable discussions
    • Small business spotlight
    • Summer party guide
    • Thought leadership
    • Wealth Management
MENU
Breadcrumb
  1. Home
  2. Greg Hinz On Politics
Greg Hinz On Politics
August 02, 2019 02:52 PM updated 3 hours ago

How much affordable housing is too much?

It's a tough question to answer, but it's one City Hall must get right as it weighs proposals that could either make Chicago more livable for many or stifle residential construction altogether.

Greg Hinz
On Politics
  • Tweet
  • Share
  • Share
  • Email
  • More
    Print
    Getty Images

    Nervous Chicago business folks won a modicum of reassurance last month when a compromise work-notice ordinance finally was crafted. The deal admittedly had some aspects of a shotgun marriage, but business groups pulled enough concessions out of Mayor Lori Lightfoot that they ended up signing off on the new law.

    Now, a much bigger test of business's relationship with the new mayor has begun. At stake literally is the health of the city's entire residential market, both rental and homeowner-occupied.

    My reference is to a series of pending proposals to expand the city's stock of affordable housing—or at least to prevent it from shrinking amid a central-area economic boom that's sparking a gentrification wave. Get it right and lower-income people will get new options to stay in town without having to starve their kids. Get it wrong and both new and renovated residential construction will dry up.

    The central proposal now on the table comes from aldermen headed by Near Southwest Side freshman Byron Sigcho-Lopez, 25th. Their plan would sharply ramp up the amount of affordable housing legally required in neighborhoods including downtown, mandating that as many as 30 percent of units in some structures be offered at well below market rates.

    Sigcho-Lopez makes a compelling case that the city's current Affordable Requirements Ordinance has been a bust, generating only 441 new units in the past decade and only 22 of them of the three-bedroom size. "We have a huge shortage of affordable housing," he says. "We're way behind what every other major city is doing."

    Sigcho-Lopez's solution is to bump up from the current 10 percent to as much as 30 percent the share of a new building's units that would have to be rented or sold at rates affordable to those who earn 30 to 80 percent of the Chicago-area median income. Also, half of those units would have to be built on-site, with the others within a half mile; current law says 25 percent on-site with the remainder within 2 miles.

    Those numbers may be doable—under certain conditions. Related Midwest President Curt Bailey, who's developing the huge 78 project in the South Loop, tells me that, in New York City, his firm operates a building that is able to charge the same rents as other nearby high-end structures even though 20 percent of its units are leased at affordable rates. That's important, because it indicates that well-off folks and their poorer neighbors actually can live together in relative harmony.

    Of course, Bailey's company gets a nice property tax rebate in New York under that state's 80/20 program. Sigcho-Lopez says he's willing to talk about offering incentives, but his ordinance does not now do so.

    The alderman also says he's willing to talk about other, potentially even more controversial sections of his bill. Like extending the 30 percent set-aside requirement to condominium towers in the central area. Or including rehab of existing rental buildings if they have at least 10 units and at least $10,000 in work is occurring in each unit. By extending the new ARO rules to rehabs and new projects that need even routine zoning changes, the proposal is getting awfully close to being an across-the-board mandate—something that could be a market killer.

    Lightfoot so far has been pretty quiet on where she'll draw the line. During the campaign, she outlined proposals that are a milder version of Sigcho-Lopez's and urged a big hike in the city's real estate transfer tax to incentivize new affordable units.

    The trick here is to find the right balance, says Geoff Smith, executive director of the housing institute at DePaul University. But by and large, all of the new, distinct high-end construction in the central area in recent years has been good for the city, he says. At the same time, he adds, most of the city's current affordable units are in two- to four-flats that are not easily regulated.

    Balance. Easy to say, but hard to achieve. I'll be watching this issue with great interest.

    Letter
    to the
    Editor

    Have something to get off your chest? You can send us an email. Or tell us on our Facebook page or on Twitter, @CrainsChicago.

    Recommended for You
    Sterling Bay hires IIT tech park leader for life sciences push
    Aldermen seek to address affordable housing, segregation
    The mayor could do LGBT constituents proud by being ... boring
    Sign up for newsletters
    EMAIL ADDRESS

    Please enter a valid email address.

    Please enter your email address.

    Please select at least one newsletter to subscribe.

    Get our newsletters

    Staying current is easy with Crain's news delivered straight to your inbox, free of charge.

    Subscribe today

    Get the best business coverage in Chicago, from breaking news to razor-sharp analysis, in print and online.

    Subscribe now
    Connect with Us
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Instagram

    CRAINS-CHICAGO-horizontal-red-wht
    Contact Us

    150 N. Michigan Ave.
    Chicago, IL 60601
    E-mail our editor
    (312) 649-5200

    More contacts

    Customer service

    Resources
    • About Us
    • Crain's Chicago jobs
    • Advertise with Us
    • Media Kit
    • Classified Advertising
    • Staff
    • Reprints
    • Ad Choices Ad Choices
    • Sitemap
    Awards
    • Special reports
    Legal
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
    Copyright © 1996-2019. Crain Communications, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
    Close